Monday, October 6, 2014

THE AFTERLIFE OF JIMMY CARTER

Jimmy Carter was a rather low-key, understated President; but I came to know more about him and admire him while I was in Stanford, as this column from Business Standard of 12 June 2000 shows.



LIFE AFTER THE DEBACLE


Nixon left his US Presidency in considerable ignominy; tainted by the Watergate scandal, he had to resign, and hand over the presidency to his Vice-President, Gerald Ford, whom Carter defeated in the 1976 election. Herbert Hoover presided over America’s worst depression, and was defeated on that account by Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the 1932 election. Lyndon Johnson, Nixon’s predecessor, was depressed by defeats in the Vietnam war, and retired to his Texas ranch to lick his wounds. Franklin Pierce took to drink.
But no president’s reputation was so comprehensively destroyed as Jimmy Carter’s. Jimmy Carter came to his Presidency amid considerable goodwill and hope. Vietnam and Watergate had mauled America’s psyche; Carter came with a clean reputation and promised to restore America’s self-regard. He, like Bill Clinton, had been governor of a small southern state, Georgia, and seemed the right man to resist the military-industrial complex that had taken the US into its own military defeat. There was an air about him of decency and calm; America looked to him to heal the national wounds.
But he was unlucky. Two years into his Presidency, Islamic militants toppled the Shah of Iran and assumed power. They raided the US embassy and took the personnel hostage. The hostage crisis lingered on, and the pacific Carter found no way out of it. Then, in his last year, oil prices suddenly shot up; that really made car-riding Americans mad. Inflation flared up, and interest rates went up to 21 per cent. In the midst of the crisis, Carter had to fight for a second term against Ronald Reagan, that beguiling charmer. It was no contest; Carter lost. What happened to him? His career after the defeat was recently described by Sara Rimer in the New York Times.
When he lost the election in 1980, Carter was 56: he still had a long life ahead of him, but his life seemed to be tatters. Carter went back to his farm in Georgia to find that he owed $1 million. He used to project himself as a simple peanut farmer, though he had been many other things, including a naval officer in a nuclear submarine. In 1961 he left the navy and built a modest ranch house in Plains, Georgia, a village of 600 people, where he still lives. Then, one day, instead of putting on his work clothes, he got into his Sunday suit. Rosalynn, his wife, was alarmed: had someone died, she asked? No; Jimmy was going to file his nomination to the Georgia senate. In 1962 he was elected and began his political career.
He did grow peanuts, but he also had a business of agricultural supplies in Atlanta. When he became President, he placed it in a blind trust. Poor management combined with droughts to ruin the business and leave it deeply in debt. He had to sell his peanut business to pay off the debts. But he still owns 3000 acres, most of it a timber plantation.
Till he was defeated, he had never stayed at home; whether as businessman, farmer, governor or president, he had had an office or a farm to go to. After his defeat, he set up an office in his garage; his wife set up her own in a bedroom. He has always been an early riser; he would get up at 5 and get to work. After he retired to Plains, there was little work, and he would finish by 9 AM – just when Rosalynn, his wife, was ready to get to work. Then he would turn up in her office for a coffee. Finally she put up a notice on her office, saying “Do not interrupt. Office hours 9 to 12”.
Anyway, in 1982 they together founded Carter Center to promote peace, human rights and health care round the world. They are helping and supporting a number of health and nutrition projects round the world.
It was Carter who brokered the Camp David accord between Israel and the PLA, which ended Arafat’s terrorism and made him ruler of Palestine. Since then, Carter has turned peacemaking into a wholesale business; whenever an honest broker is needed, people think of him. Look at his recent engagements. He brokered an agreement between Uganda and Sudan. In December, when Panama became independent from the US, he represented the US government. The previous month he monitored the elections in Mozambique; till now he has monitored 29 elections. For his work in disease prevention, he was given an honorary doctorate by the London School of Tropical Medicine. His Center runs a project that brings better agricultural techniques to villagers in Mali.
All this worldwide activity involves considerable travel; so Jim and Rosalynn accumulate a lot of frequent flyer miles. They use the miles to take their children and grandchildren on holiday at Christmas. They have three sons and a daughter, and the daughter has just had a son, Hugo – 21st of their descendants. The clan has been on holiday to Disneyland, Colorado, Mexico and Belize.
In the middle of all this traveling, Carter manages to do quite a bit of writing. He has written 14 books, including one on the virtues of aging; another, written with his wife, is entitled “Everything to gain: making the most of the rest of your life”. At the moment he is writing a novel – no, not Primary Colors Vol 2.  He is an expert carpenter; he does all the repairs in his house; he has made his own bed, and he makes furniture to relax. Emory University has made him a distinguished professor; there he lectures on various topics such as politics and health care. He started skiing at 62, climbed Kilimanjaro at 64, and Mount Fuji at 70.
But maybe this late precocity is not unusual in the son of Miss Lillian, a registered nurse who ran a nursing home. At 68 she joined the Peace Corps and came to India for two years in the 1960s. (That was before Indira Gandhi banned the Peace Corps volunteers, saying they were spies; the government is still to remove the ban, or indeed the draconian restrictions on long-stay visitors that L K Advani’s home ministry administers.) She went back to the States and gave 500 speeches on being active in old age. She died at 85. Today, at 76, her son is one of the old people the Americans admire most.

Carter’s example encourages me, for I too thought that my career had been destroyed at 57 by the kiss of death that my brief time in the government proved to be. But I survived, thanks to BS, and I have gone on to do things I would once have thought impossible. I am not sure I would go and climb Kilimanjaro. But anything is possible. And one does not have to wait to get old for it to happen. Who knows? It may happen to you tomorrow. But you have to go and build your own fortune.

Friday, October 3, 2014

UNQUALIFIED PARENTS

This continues the argument in the previous column.


SHOULD PARENTHOOD NEED QUALIFICATION?


Last November I wrote a column proposing that boys should have to take a test to qualify for being allowed to be schooled with girls. Of two mothers, one said that girls could learn to survive in a men’s world only by dealing with boys at an early age: that she had so much trouble handling her male colleagues because she went to a girls’ school, and she had sent her daughter to a coeducational school. Another mother wrote just the opposite: that she would never have succeeded so well in an IIM and later in professional life if she had not been sheltered in a girls’ school. But she said something else that was interesting: that parents should also have to qualify to send a child to school. That set me thinking.
There are supposed to be 3½ million adults in California alone who are functionally illiterate – that is, who cannot take a written driving test or fill in an official form. California has a special problem because many have migrated from Mexico and do not know English. But the whole of US has a problem with public schooling: it leaves millions uneducated.
The conservative diagnosis of the problem is that teachers in government schools have secure jobs and do not teach; the solution is to introduce competition. Ever since racially separate schools were struck down by the Supreme Court in the 1960s, children have a right and an obligation to go to a neighbourhood government school. So they are obliged to go to one of the nearest government schools – unless their parents pay to send them to private school. If the nearest school does not teach, it is just the children’s bad luck. What the conservatives advocate is that children should be given all or part of the cost the state government incurs to go and spend it on attending any school of their choice. Naturally, teachers’ unions oppose such proposals tooth and nail.
But three States have introduced school vouchers on a limited scale. Florida has started giving schoolchildren a standardized test. If a school’s students fail the test twice in four years, then they can go to another school; the State would give the child the tuition fee in a private school or the average cost per student in the district’s government schools, whichever is lower. The tests were introduced only recently, so only 53 students have migrated, but soon 60,000 will become eligible. Ohio has introduced a pilot project in Cleveland. If a family’s income is below twice the federally defined poverty level, its children qualify to migrate to a private school. They are given 90 per cent of the fee if the family is below the poverty line and 75 per cent if it is below twice the poverty line, but in no case more than $2250 a year. The lucky children are chosen by lottery – 3484 this year. The Milwaukee scheme is similar: the cutoff is 175 per cent of the poverty level, and the maximum fee payable is $5106. Not more than 15 per cent of the students of government schools can migrate; this year the number is 7996. In addition, rich activists have privately funded a Children’s scholarship fund. Their limit is 270 per cent of the poverty level. They contribute a part of the fee; the average is $1000. They get 1.25 million applications, and fund about 40,000 students.
Jodi Wilgoren of The New York Times visited two schools in Florida that had lost students as a result of migration; the impact on them was electric. They have recruited more teachers and reduced class size. They have dropped science and social studies which do not figure in the State tests, and started concentrating on eligible subjects – reading, writing and mathematics. They have stopped school picnics, and instead introduced “test fairs” – on Saturdays the children come and take mock tests. The tests typically involve multiple-choice questions; so the students are taught how to narrow down the choice – and thus increase the probability of getting the answer right. In other words, the schools have become more like the private tutorial classes one finds all over India.
Not all the arguments against school vouchers are self-serving: the question is, how far is the poor performance of children the fault of teachers, and how far due to other causes. Poorly performing children come from poor families, often families headed by single mothers or even grandmothers, for many single mothers abandon the children and grandmothers adopt them out of pity. They come from families which have never seen a book. They are often children seen as superfluous or a nuisance, who never get any sympathy from adults. America’s youngest murderer, a child of six, shot dead a girl in his class in February. His 25-year-old father was in jail, his mother was a drug addict. He had no bed in his house, and slept wherever he could find space and peace. It is doubtful if he got regular meals. Newborns or infants are often found left dead in rubbish heaps. Not all families are this bad. But there are many families in which children live on sufferance; education is a very low priority amongst the parents of such children.
Besides, if children are allowed to migrate, not all will be able to. Only those can who are taken by better schools. The better schools will also be worried about their standards, and will take only the better students. So the poor schools will be left with the worst students, and will become even more hopeless.
Even if the government pays the entire fees of a private school, sending a child to one inevitably entails additional costs for books, materials, uniforms etc; in India there would also be the costs of the schools’ ad hoc demands for money. A family has to be able and prepared to incur these. Really poor families may not be able to.
And then, a child does not become good simply by going to a good school. It becomes good by doing homework. It must have the minimum space and quiet at home to do it; and it would do far better if its parents actually helped her. These familial inputs are not available to many American children.

In a free society like America, it would be unthinkable; but we in India should be asking ourselves whether couples should not have to qualify to have a child. Activists in advanced countries get very exercised over child labour in India. But if they have to labour, it is not the children’s fault; it is their parents’ fault. We might, like good socialists, forbear to say that loudly: after all, poverty is a misfortune, not a fault. But one does not have to pass on the misfortune to a child; that is sheer cruelty. Especially these days when conception is perfectly controllable, surely it is not unreasonable to expect people to control it if they do not have the means to bring up a child. They can have all the fun without the responsibility of bringing up a child.

IS THE SOCIETY A BAD INFLUENCE?

We regard India as a country of many religions; but the US has many more - they just do not call them religions. It is also a country of freedom, and that freedom includes freedom to own guns. These adult peculiarities get reflected in children, and create peculiar problems for schools, as this column in Business Standard of 16 May 2000 relates.


SCHOOLING AS SOCIALIZATION


In November I wrote saying that many Indian parents fear the influence of boys in coeducational schools upon their daughters and suggested that boys should have to qualify as civilized beings before being admitted in coeducational schools. The response to the article from men was a deathly silence. But two women responded. One said that her remarkably high level of achievement – she went to an IIM and became a successful consultant – was due to the fact that she had gone to a girls’ school as well as college and did not waste time competing with boys under rules they set. But apparently her daughter, who was in a coeducational school, dissented. Another woman blamed her difficulties in a man’s world upon the fact that she had been to a girls’ school; she had sent her daughter to a coeducational school and felt that the daughter was far better able to cope with men.
Meanwhile here in America, a very different kind of debate goes on about schooling. Here children every once in a while shoot their fellow-students; far more often, they smoke, take drugs, swear or fight. So parents try to keep their children out of schools where they might run such risks; and white parents believe that the risks are greater where black or Hispanic children are present in strength (although to date, white children have shown themselves to be as eager to shoot people as non-white ones). Vice and violence are also more rife in big cities; so parents often move to small towns where they hope children will be better behaved. I read about a New York couple that had moved to a distant suburb in that hope. There, their ten-year-old son’s class was detained during the recess as punishment for talking. The children there are asked to keep a diary; in the diary, the boy, Misha, described his teacher as an arse, if I have guessed right. She reported him to the principal, who transferred the kid to another class. Then the other kids told the teacher that the boy had unloaded techniques of making bombs from the internet, and talked of bringing a gun. Their parents started ringing her, worried that their children might be shot. Then a kid spotted Misha carrying a key chain on which there was a miniature device – it had a nail file, a pair of scissors and a small knife (I myself keep one in my office, to open letters and as a souvenir of Switzerland). Misha was suspended for a week. When he went back to school, he could no longer do so on the school bus; he rode alone, with an escort or a guard as the case may be.
Parents’ worries are bound to affect politics; and political responses are bound to be impulsive and often stupid. Thus some States are proposing to reduce to fourteen the age at which a killer can be convicted. Another movement that is gaining ground is to get around a ban on the posting of Ten Commandments in schools that the Supreme Court imposed a couple of decades ago (one of which is, “Thou shalt not kill”), on the ground that the US Constitution prohibits religious instruction in schools. The way they hope to defeat the Supreme Court is by calling Ten Commandments a historical document. A conservative group called Family Research Group has given children thousands of book covers bearing the Ten commandments.
Behind this malaise is the fact that American schools are powerful instruments of socialization; when they enter schools, children effectively leave the home as a formative institution, and join the peer group of their fellow schoolchildren. There they pick up slang (I do not understand their lingo too well; but every third word is “like” – not in the sense of liking – or any other sense). They acquire hobbies, of which drugs are only one. They are initiated into a world of fashion, which includes sneakers, make-up and shape-up brassieres or shapeless sweatshirts. They form armies and wage wars. Teachers do not even try to restrain them. Some of them may be scared of being shot, like the teacher in the school I earlier described. But the threat of a lawsuit by a parent is a more potent deterrent.
In the circumstances, many parents are looking for a way out of the system. Almost a quarter of Americans today are Christian conservatives of one sort or another. They are a powerful force in politics, and have considerable influence in the Republican Party. Many of them send their children to religious schools. But a surprising number of parents have taken their children out of school altogether, and are educating them at home. Apparently there are more than a million of them. Margaret Talbot described one of them – a family with seven children – in The New York Times in picturesque detail. The father is 39, an airline pilot; he comes from a broken family where the children were free to do what they liked; his father played piano in clubs and drank. The mother was a tennis player in school; after she injured herself, she began dating at 15, and that led to beach parties and drinking. The two joined and met at a Christian group called Young Life. Now they live half an hour out of a Pennsylvania township. They rigorously shield their children from what they consider immoral influences, including other children and television. The children are schooled by their mother in reading, writing and arithmetic. The parents used to watch adult movies – though not blue films – after putting their children to bed; but now they feel they should shun the vices they want to protect their children from, and they no longer do. According to Talbott, “To a girl and a boy, the Sheibner kids are a pleasure to talk to; they are polite and brimming with book-gotten information. They’re also a little otherworldly, a bit unnervingly preprogrammed.”
But so are the “normal” American kids; to my alien eyes, they are equally otherworldly and preprogrammed. I am only used to middle-class American households. But even amongst them, children would hardly ever mix naturally with adults. Generally they would be doing “their own thing” – playing computer games, phoning friends, or playing loud music. If they come down for dinner, they would make the minimum eye contact, let alone conversation. They would eat self-absorbed, and leave without taking leave. Often their parents would dismiss them – ask them to go to their room. It is a war of generations, and children are not always the aggressors.

The Sheibners’ devoutness is a reaction to the terrifying alienation of children in the United States. It makes me wonder: what can the rise of Hindu and Muslim zealotry in India be traced to? We find Murli Manohar Joshi’s attempts to communalize education unedifying; but is it as poorly conceived a solution to a real problem as the distribution of Ten Commandments in the US is? We regard madrasas as the breeding grounds of communalism and separatism; but do Muslim children have something to fear from broader contact with Indian society?

THE ABDUCTION OF ELIAN

[We are familiar with the postwar unfriendliness of the US and Russia; Fiedel Castro's conquest of Cuba and its conversion into an island of socialism also made news in 1959. I became aware of the human costs of this little piece of cold war only when I was in America. This was published in Business Standard of 9 May 2000.]


THE SAGA OF ELIAN GONZALEZ


On 25 November, two fishermen fishing off the coast of Florida saw something dark floating on the sea. Getting closer, they found a tyre tube, with a child hanging desperately on to it. The boy was famished and dehydrated. They rushed him to a hospital in Miami. Lázaro Gonzalez, a Cuban emigré, claimed him to be Elian, his grandnephew, and took him home.
Just two days earlier, seven people had held on to the tube that Elian was found hanging on to. They were amongst the fourteen whose boat had capsized; it had only two tubes, and they divided into two groups of seven each. One by one, all dropped off, eaten by sharks, chilled by the sea, or half dead of thirst. They included Elisabeth Broton, Elian’s mother. Before she gave up, she gave him her last bottle of water.
Elisabeth was escaping from Cuba with her boy friend, Lázaro Rafael Munero, and his family. Lázaro was a casual worker who sometimes sold soft drinks on the beach or drove a taxi. In summer 1997 he had once before escaped to Miami and lived with his aunt. After doing low-paid casual jobs for a few months he got homesick, bought a motorized rubber raft, and made it back to Cuba. There he was picked up by the Cuban coast guard, beaten up and jailed for two months. When he was released, he went first to live with Elisa and her mother. Her mother did not like him, so they moved into a rented apartment. But soon the call of Yuma – as the Cubans call America – beckoned him. He got hold of a homemade boat, persuaded his family as well as Elisa, and set off northwards late in the night of 21 November.
By the afternoon of the 22nd, their escape was common knowledge, and Juan Miguel Gonzalez, Elian’s father, was worried. Elisa and he had got married when they were both in their teens and working in hotels on the beach near Cárdenas. They had done well enough to build a little house and buy a second-hand car. But then Juan Miguel started chasing other women. The marriage broke up, and Elisa went to live with her parents. Juan Miguel married Nersy, with whom he has an eight-month-old son.
Guessing what had happened, Juan Miguel rang up Lázaro, his father Juan’s brother in Miami. Lázaro knew nothing that could help, but promised to keep a watch. When Elian was taken to hospital, Lázaro went there and claimed him. He rang up Juan Miguel and told him that Elian was safe, though his mother was drowned.
Elian is a sweet, photogenic kid, and made big news. His grand-uncle sent him to a local school; he started learning to play baseball, and made new friends. The press soon made him a celebrity.
Apart from Lázaro, Juan Miguel had three uncles and four aunts, all brothers and sisters of his father. Of the nine siblings, six were in Miami, and three in Cuba. The elders in Miami started ringing him and telling him to come over: Elian had attracted contributions and publicity, and they were sure Juan Miguel could get a house, a job and all the comforts of the US.
But comforts were not all that was involved. By then, the publicity given to Elian attracted Cuban emigré politicians in Miami, who had made a career out of enmity to Castro. They had supporters amongst the local Cuban people, many of whom had suffered grievously under Castro before they were allowed to emigrate or had illegally escaped. For them, keeping Elian in the US was a blow for freedom; sending him back to Cuba was to send him into slavery. A politician named Armando Gutierrez took the Lázaro Ganzalez family under his wing.
Equally, the publicity made Elian a prize in Cuba. Soon after he became a press celebrity, Juan Miguel was summoned to Havana, and taken before El Jefe (the Chief), as Fidel Castro is called in Cuba. Apparently, Castro told him to choose – that he would allow Juan Miguel to migrate if he wanted. Juan Miguel said he was not going to. Then the Cuban government sent a diplomatic note to the US government to return Elian.
In Washington, the person in the hot seat was Janet Reno, who is the secretary in charge of Justice Department. In their eyes, Elian was an illegal alien, and had to be returned to his country of origin unless specified circumstances argued otherwise – unless, for instance, he was likely to be tortured or oppressed in his home country. Also, according to US law, he was a minor, and had no voice of his own; he had to be represented by one of his parents – namely, Juan Miguel. US diplomats in Havana interviewed Juan Miguel, and found him to be normal, and willing to take his son. So the only question in the eye of Janet Reno was, how to transfer Elian to Juan Miguel.
But that would require Elian to be separated from the family of Lázaro, who was by then determined to keep Elian. Even if he were not, there was Gutierrez asking him to strike a blow for freedom, there were agents from New York offering him deals to write a book or make a film – and there were crowds outside his house, shouting death to Reno. He filed a case in a family court for the custody of Elian; he lost. Then he filed an appeal; and the Federal Appeals Court came to a curious decision. It decided that since the appeal had been filed in Elian’s name, he was plaintiff. The Immigration and Naturalization Service, which had to decide on his extradition, had not interviewed him to ascertain his wishes. In the circumstances, the Court deferred the hearing to 9 May.
So on the night of Saturday the 22nd April, immigration agents with submachine guns stormed the Lázaro Gonzalez family home. They broke open the front door, rushed past the terrified residents, and found Donato Dalrymple, one of the fishermen who had found Elian, hiding in a wardrobe. They whisked away the screaming child, bundled him into a white station wagon, and sped him to an airport. He was flown to Washington, and taken to his father.
Two photographs dominated the next day’s newspapers. One, taken by a press photographer, showed a gunman facing the fisherman and the boy in the wardrobe; the other showed a smiling Elian in his father’s arms. But both were overshadowed by a press conference given by the Lázaro family, friends and supporters. Lázaro’s 21-year-old daughter, Marisleysis, held the center stage with an impassioned, tearful outpouring of indignation. She had looked after Elian all these months, and was obviously ravaged by his loss.

I have gathered all this from the press and television, sitting three thousand miles away from the seat of events. Although its sensationalism and raw polemics put me off, I must say that competition drives the US media to make news more compelling than fiction; as a result they involve the people of America far more closely in public affairs than we in India do. That is what we miss.